The Way of Truth Fellowship lion logoThe Way of Truth Fellowship
Join Bible Study

Truth vs. Tradition

Christmas and the Birth of Messiah

What does Scripture actually say about when and how Messiah was born?
← Back to Truth vs. Tradition

Supporting Scriptures

The Commonly Held Belief

Messiah was born on December 25, and Christmas is the biblical celebration of His birth.

What Scripture Says

Scripture records the birth of Yahusha (Luke 2; Matthew 1–2) but gives no date and commands no annual celebration of it. Shepherds were in the fields at night (Luke 2:8), which some take to suggest a season other than winter. Yahuah warns against worshiping Him in the ways the nations worshiped their gods (Deuteronomy 12:30–32).

Historical Background

December 25 is first attested as a celebration of Messiah's birth in Rome in the 4th century (the Chronograph of 354). Scholars debate whether it was chosen to replace Roman winter festivals (such as Sol Invictus) or calculated from a believed date of conception. Many customs (trees, gift-bringers) developed much later in Europe.

Our Fellowship's Understanding

Because Scripture neither dates nor commands the celebration, we do not observe Christmas, and we focus instead on the appointed times Yahuah gave. We rejoice in Messiah's birth every day.

Other Major Interpretations

Most Christians see Christmas as a permissible way to honor the incarnation, citing liberty in Romans 14. Some Protestants historically (e.g., the Puritans) rejected it.

Questions Worth Examining

  • Why would Scripture record the feasts in detail yet omit Messiah's birth date?
  • Does Deuteronomy 12:30–32 apply to how believers worship today?

Further Reading

  • Susan K. Roll, Toward the Origins of Christmas (1995)
  • Andrew McGowan, 'How December 25 Became Christmas', Biblical Archaeology Review

Published November 17, 2026